Loading
in Cloverdale, CA
Cloverdale investors face a clear choice: conventional loans that scrutinize your W-2 income, or DSCR loans that only care if the rental property pays for itself. Your employment situation and property type determine which path makes sense.
Conventional loans offer lower rates but require tax returns and income verification. DSCR loans skip the paperwork headache but cost more upfront. We see both work well in Sonoma County's rental market—just for different borrower profiles.
Conventional loans deliver the best rates in Cloverdale—typically 0.5% to 1% below DSCR pricing. You need strong credit (usually 680+), full tax returns, and provable income. Investment properties require 15-25% down depending on whether it's a second home or rental.
These loans work great for W-2 earners with straightforward tax returns. You'll hit debt-to-income ratio limits, so existing mortgages and car payments matter. If you're self-employed with heavy write-offs, your tax returns might not show enough qualifying income.
DSCR loans qualify you based solely on rental income versus the mortgage payment. No tax returns, no pay stubs, no employer verification. You need 20-25% down and credit above 660. The property must generate enough rent to cover the mortgage—usually a 1.0 to 1.25 ratio.
These loans cost more—expect rates 1.5% to 2.5% higher than conventional. But they let you scale a rental portfolio without hitting income limits. Self-employed borrowers and investors with multiple properties use these to avoid DTI constraints that conventional loans impose.
Rate difference matters most on Cloverdale properties. On a $600K loan, that 2% rate gap costs about $700 monthly. Conventional requires proving your personal income works with the new payment. DSCR only cares if market rent covers the mortgage—your other income is irrelevant.
Documentation splits these loans completely. Conventional demands two years of tax returns, W-2s, and full asset verification. DSCR needs a lease agreement or rent schedule—that's it. Processing time runs 30-45 days for conventional, 20-30 days for DSCR since there's less to verify.
Choose conventional if you have W-2 income and clean tax returns showing strong earnings. The rate savings compound over time, and you're not paying extra for flexibility you don't need. It's the default choice for first or second investment properties when your DTI allows it.
Go DSCR if you're self-employed with write-offs, already own multiple rentals, or your tax returns don't reflect actual cash flow. The higher rate is the cost of avoiding income verification. We also use DSCR for properties that need immediate rental income qualification before tax season.
No. DSCR loans only work for investment properties that generate rental income. You need conventional or other loan types for primary residences.
Most lenders require rent to equal 100-125% of the full mortgage payment including taxes and insurance. We use market rent analysis or existing lease agreements.
Usually yes. Conventional loans rarely have prepayment penalties. Some DSCR loans carry penalties for 1-3 years depending on the lender.
Yes, through refinancing. If your income situation improves or DTI allows it, refinancing to conventional can lower your rate significantly.
DSCR typically closes 10-15 days faster since there's less documentation to verify. Conventional requires full underwriting of personal financials.